An Elephant Sitting Still
2018 · Hu Bo
In the northern Chinese city of Manzhouli, they say there is an elephant that simply sits and ignores the world. Manzhouli becomes an obsession for the protagonists of this film, a longed-for escape from the downward spiral in which they find themselves.
dir. Hu Bo · 2018
One grey dawn to one grey dusk in a decaying industrial city in northern China: a bullied schoolboy, a girl entangled with a teacher, a small-time hood, and an old man being pushed toward a nursing home all drift toward the same rumor — an elephant in Manzhouli that sits still and ignores the world. Hu Bo, a novelist turned filmmaker, shot his only feature in long, prowling Steadicam takes that hold on the back of a character's head while the world blurs behind them, so that four hours pass as one continuous held breath. The bleakness is total, yet the film keeps flaring with tenderness — strangers offering each other small, useless kindnesses. Hu died by suicide at twenty-nine, before the premiere, after clashes with his producers over the cut; the film screened at the Berlinale as his testament and won the Golden Horse for best picture. It belongs with the great Chinese films of stalled lives, and its final minutes contain one of modern cinema's most piercing sounds, arriving out of darkness.
Lines of influence
- Sátántangó (1994) — Tarr personally mentored Hu Bo at a Beijing masterclass, and Elephant's punishing feature-length long takes and mud-grey provincial despair are lifted directly from Tarr's choreographed roving-camera grammar.
- The Turin Horse (2011) — The reduced monochromatic palette and slow gliding takes that hold on characters mired in stalled, repetitive lives are the Tarr method Hu Bo absorbed as his student.
- Elephant (2003) — Harris Savides' steadicam trailing students from behind through corridors — back-of-head framing across a multi-strand single day converging toward violence — is the exact device (and title motif) Hu Bo rebuilds.
- Elephant (1989) — Clarke originated the relentless steadicam-behind-the-walking-figure tracking that Van Sant and then Hu Bo inherited as their governing camera logic.
- Gerry (2002) — Unbroken steadicam follows of drifting figures, holding on the back of the head while the world blurs — the shallow-focus following aesthetic Fan Chao adopts for Hu Bo.
- Xiao Wu (1997) — Founded the Chinese independent grammar of trailing a drifting loner through a decaying provincial town in observational social realism — the template Hu Bo works within.
- A Touch of Sin (2013) — Its braided multi-strand structure of separate despairing lives across contemporary China's economic underside prefigures Elephant's interweaving four-character design.
- West of the Tracks (2002) — Marathon-length takes of rusting northeastern industrial decay establish the exact bleak rust-belt milieu and durational endurance Hu Bo channels.
- Vive L'Amour (1994) — Long, patient held takes on inarticulate young people paralyzed by urban alienation model the tenderness-amid-emptiness register Elephant sustains.
- The Passenger (1975) — Antonioni's roving, subject-detaching camera and studies of alienation with expressive shallow-focus isolation are the modernist root of Hu Bo's estranging framing.
- Once Upon a Time in Anatolia (2011) — A multi-strand ensemble crawling across a single night in bleak provincial landscape, its long takes finding small human kindnesses inside institutional despair — the same tonal architecture.
- Kaili Blues (2015) — A contemporary of Hu Bo pushing the Chinese long-take toward extended roving mobile-camera passages through decaying small-town China.
- Dwelling in the Fuchun Mountains (2019) — Extends the same post-2018 Chinese independent long-take realism — patient tracking of ordinary family lives stalled in a changing provincial economy.
- The Wild Goose Lake (2019) — Shares the bleak northern-China industrial-fringe setting and the tailing of desperate figures through grimy nocturnal spaces in shallow focus.
- Norte, the End of History (2013) — Contemporary slow-cinema durational endurance and moral bleakness, using extended real-time takes to trap characters inside stalled, hopeless lives.
- 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days (2007) — Compresses its social-realist dread into a single grim day of long unbroken takes, the same time-unity-plus-duration device Hu Bo builds his structure on.