Sightlines · reception
How The Death of Robin Hood was received
2026 · Michael Sarnoski · The Death of Robin Hood on Sightlines
The arc
Too new for a reappraisal arc — it landed in June 2026 as A24's grim, revisionist swing at the legend and split critics on arrival: 'the Unforgiven of Robin Hood movies' to admirers, a self-serious slog to detractors. The Letterboxd crowd adopted it as a discourse object from day one.
What’s debated
Is stripping Robin Hood of the tights, the merry men and even 'steal from the rich' a bold act of myth-excavation, or joyless prestige grimness — and is Jackman just doing Logan again in chainmail?
Its footprint
Its cultural currency so far is the 'Logan comparison' — every review and podcast reached for Jackman's other dying-legend swan song — plus the instantly shareable pitch that it's the Unforgiven of Robin Hood movies.
Where it stands
A newborn canon-contender: the kind of divisive, director-driven A24 release Letterboxd users log early and argue about, with its long-term standing still wide open.
Did you know? Sarnoski built the film from the medieval ballad 'Robin Hood's Death' he'd read as a kid, setting it in a real 1274 and deliberately discarding the famous bits — 'steal from the rich,' the Crusades, Richard the Lionheart — because all of them were bolted onto the legend centuries later.
Named by the director
- Robin Hood (1973) — Sarnoski has said Disney's animated version was part of his childhood entry into the legend, and it sits on his published Letterboxd list of ten influences.
- The Virgin Spring (1960) — Named on Sarnoski's official Letterboxd list of ten films that influenced his take — Bergman's stark medieval tale of violence and faith.
- Valhalla Rising (2009) — On Sarnoski's published Letterboxd influences list — Refn's brutal, near-wordless medieval odyssey.
- The Revenant (2015) — On Sarnoski's published Letterboxd influences list — Iñárritu's visceral wounded-man survival epic.
- The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007) — On Sarnoski's published Letterboxd influences list — another elegy about the gap between an outlaw and his legend.
- Days of Heaven (1978) — On Sarnoski's published Letterboxd influences list — Malick's natural-light pastoral lyricism.
- Phantom Thread (2017) — On Sarnoski's published Letterboxd influences list — an intimate, thorny two-hander between a difficult man and his caretaker.
- The Princess Bride (1987) — The list's curveball: named on Sarnoski's official Letterboxd influences list — a storybook adventure about how tales get told and retold.