Sightlines · reception
How Velvet Goldmine was received
1998 · Todd Haynes · Velvet Goldmine on Sightlines
The arc
Booed-adjacent at Cannes '98 (it did win a jury prize for Artistic Contribution) and a box-office flop that even some critics called a glittery mess, it's since been fully reclaimed — now a beloved queer cult classic that many rank among Todd Haynes' best.
What’s debated
The eternal fan debate: was David Bowie right to refuse his songs — protecting his own myth — or did his veto accidentally make the film better by forcing it to become its own invented mythology?
Its footprint
A foundational text of queer internet fandom — its glitter, green brooch, and Ewan McGregor/Jonathan Rhys Meyers imagery have circulated on Tumblr and Letterboxd for years, and 'We set out to change the world... ended up just changing ourselves' is endlessly quoted.
Where it stands
A textbook cult object: ignored in 1998, now a 'you must have seen this' rite of passage for queer cinephiles and glam-rock devotees alike.
Did you know? David Bowie refused to license his songs to the film — reportedly saving his Ziggy Stardust story for his own project — so Haynes filled the soundtrack with covers and originals by members of Radiohead, Suede, Sonic Youth and more, with R.E.M.'s Michael Stipe on board as executive producer.
Named by the director
- Citizen Kane (1941) — Haynes openly borrowed its reporter-investigates-an-enigma structure as the film's narrative spine.
- Performance (1970) — Haynes cited it as one of the trip-like 'youth-experience films' of the era he wanted to recreate.
- 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) — Named by Haynes alongside Performance as the kind of overwhelming late-60s cinematic 'trip' he was chasing.
- A Clockwork Orange (1971) — Also on Haynes' declared list of immersive youth-experience films that shaped the film's non-linear, sensory approach.