Sightlines · a reading
A Deleuzian reading of The Longest Day
1962 · Ken Annakin · The Longest Day on Sightlines
A man hangs from a church steeple at Sainte-Mère-Église, his parachute snagged on the stonework, the bells hammering his ears deaf, while the battle for the town goes on below him without his help. He can only look. In a film assembled almost entirely out of men deciding and then acting, here is one who has been stripped of both at once: conscious, suspended, useless. Keep him in mind. He is the exception that tells you what everything around him is.
Because The Longest Day is, almost defiantly, a movement-image film — the kind Deleuze describes as a closed circuit where a character perceives a situation and acts to change it, where action resolves the situation and the cutting exists to serve that chain. Annakin and Zanuck's invasion is the genre at full sensory-motor power. And it works in what Deleuze calls the large form of the action-image: a global situation bears down — the Atlantic Wall going up under Rommel's inspection, the weather locked over the Channel, two massed armies waiting — and the whole apparatus tightens toward one colossal answering deed, the landing. Rommel naming the problem to his officers (stop them on the beach) is the situation announcing itself; the dawn assault is the act that transforms it. Deleuze's word for that encompassing situation is the synsign, the milieu that calls the action out of the men inside it. D-Day is one of the purest synsigns the cinema has staged, because it really did encompass everyone in frame.
Watch how the film keeps breathing between the immense and the single figure. It pulls back until the CinemaScope frame is solid with men and machines — masses photographed as one moving body, what Deleuze calls the dividual, a crowd rendered as a single unit of feeling rather than a sum of individuals — and then it presses in on one paratrooper, one bagpiper walking the beach through fire. That alternation of vast milieu-space and the taut line of a particular action is respiration-space: the film inhales the scale of the operation, exhales onto a face.
And the editing that binds four nations into one day is the oldest tool in the movement-image kit, scaled to a continent. Griffith's convergent parallel montage — the cross-cutting that races separate strands toward a single meeting point — here intercuts the German command, the American airborne drops, the British beaches, the French commandos, all of them aimed at the same hour. The last-minute rescue logic of 1916 becomes the logic of an invasion.
Here is where the film gets genuinely strange to a Deleuzian, and where the lens pays off. Everything that makes The Longest Day unusual is, in Deleuze's history, a symptom of the action-image breaking. He argues that after the war the old circuit fell apart through dispersion — too many characters too weakly linked, slackened causality, the trip that changes nothing. The all-star mosaic, four dozen famous faces each given a scene and dropped, the polyphony of untranslated German and French, the refusal of a single protagonist: by the logic of Cinema 1 this is the dispersive situation that should dissolve action into drift. The film has every one of the symptoms. What it does is cure them. It takes dispersal and uses it as architecture, then reconverges every strand onto the beach. The Longest Day is the action-image's last monumental consolidation, achieved with the very materials that were dissolving it everywhere else in 1962.
Its authority comes from a bet Bazin would have recognized. Shooting in black-and-white at the height of color spectacle binds the images to the newsreel and the combat photograph, to the look of the record rather than the look of drama. The deep, populated compositions, the overcast gray, the men speaking their own languages with subtitles — this is the realist contract, the faith that the image testifies. The famous gliding aerial sweep over Ouistreham, one unbroken take floating above the commando assault, is in Deleuze's terms a mobile section: camera movement that expresses a change in the whole rather than just covering action. But its god's-eye detachment carries a faint shiver of that hanging man — a vision that surveys and cannot intervene.
The lineage is a craft inheritance, not a vague mood. The sympathetic, professionally drawn German officers descend directly from All Quiet on the Western Front, which first granted the enemy's foot soldiers full interiority. The monochrome documentary idiom is borrowed deliberately from the combat-camera work of The Memphis Belle and the journalist's-eye reconstruction of The Story of G.I. Joe; the deep-populated tableau comes through They Were Expendable. The collective-over-individual structure — many strands, one operation — is Battleground's prototype enlarged. And Zanuck functioning as the single author over three national directorial units is Selznick's producer-authorship from Gone with the Wind, industrialized. Downstream, this film fixed the template of the all-star, multi-strand war epic for the next fifteen years.
Its significance, then, is almost paradoxical and entirely concrete: it proved the action-image could absorb its own crisis. The dispersal that would become Antonioni's drift and the modern seer is here marshalled back into a working circuit. Which returns us to the steeple. The film can show one man reduced to pure looking, an accidental voyant — and then it can cut away, back to the men who still act. In 1962 the cinema could still choose to cut away. That choice is what the film is about, and watching it again, you feel exactly how hard it was to keep.
Concepts in play
- action-image (large form) — The global situation of the Atlantic Wall, the locked weather, and two massed armies bears down until the single transforming deed of the dawn landing answers it; Rommel's 'stop them on the beach' states the situation, the assault resolves it
- the encompasser (synsign) — D-Day itself as the encompassing milieu that calls action out of every nationality, announced by Rommel touring the defenses
- organic/American convergent montage — Parallel cross-cutting among German command, American airborne, British beaches, and French commandos, all converging on a single dawn — Griffith's last-minute convergence scaled to a continent
- respiration-space — The film's alternation between pulling back to the panoramic scale of the operation and pressing in on single figures (the bagpiper, the paratrooper)
- dispersive situation — The Altman-esque all-star mosaic — four dozen stars each given a scene, no single protagonist, untranslated languages, weakly linked strands — the very symptom Deleuze ties to the crisis of the action-image, here reconverged rather than dissolved
- the Open — Rommel's line that 'for the Allies as well as the Germans, it will be the longest day' opens the framed single day onto the whole of the war
- the mobile section (plan) — The sustained unbroken gliding aerial take over the commando assault at Ouistreham, camera movement expressing a change in the whole with a god's-eye detachment