Sightlines · reception
How Chimes at Midnight was received
1965 · Orson Welles · Chimes at Midnight on Sightlines
The arc
Dismissed by many American critics on its 1966 release (Bosley Crowther panned it) and then nearly impossible to see for decades due to rights disputes, it's now widely ranked among Welles's greatest films — a status cemented by its 2016 restoration and Criterion release.
What’s debated
The perennial cinephile fight: is this — not Citizen Kane — actually Welles's masterpiece, and does its famously rough, post-dubbed sound matter or add to the charm?
Its footprint
The Battle of Shrewsbury sequence is one of the most imitated battle scenes ever shot — its muddy, chaotic staging echoes through Branagh's Henry V and decades of war films.
Where it stands
A former holy grail of hard-to-see cinema turned canon climber — now firmly a 'you must see this' among Welles devotees and Shakespeare-on-film lists.
Did you know? Welles got the film funded by promising producer Emiliano Piedra he'd also make a Treasure Island adaptation — a film he reportedly never intended to deliver; he later said of Chimes: 'If I wanted to get into heaven on the basis of one movie, that's the one I'd offer up.'