
2006 · John Lasseter
How Cars has been received, argued over, and remembered.
In 2006 it landed as Pixar's first critical shrug — solid grosses but the studio's lowest Rotten Tomatoes score to that point, and it lost the animation Oscar to Happy Feet. Twenty years on it's split into two reputations: cinephiles still rank it near the bottom of Pixar, while the kids who grew up on it defend it as sincere Americana about slowing down.
The forever-fight: is Cars the moment Pixar chose merchandise over storytelling, or an unfairly maligned, heartfelt film that just had the bad luck of following The Incredibles?
'Ka-chow!' and Lightning McQueen are permanent meme fixtures, the franchise became a ten-billion-dollar-plus merchandising empire, Cars Land got built at Disney California Adventure, and Rascal Flatts' 'Life Is a Highway' cover is inseparable from the film.
A generational split-vote on Letterboxd: reflexive 'worst Pixar' punching bag for older cinephiles, sincere nostalgic comfort-watch for everyone born after about 1998.
Influences John Lasseter has publicly named — the director's own word, distinct from the inferred lines of influence.