Sightlines · reception
How Smile was received
2022 · Parker Finn · Smile on Sightlines
The arc
Written off by some in 2022 as another studio jump-scare machine, it became one of the decade's great horror sleeper hits — and when Smile 2 (2024) landed to even warmer reviews, the first film got retroactive credit as the foundation of an actually-good franchise.
What’s debated
The forever-fight: is Smile a clever trauma-horror hit or the moment the 'trauma is the monster' metaphor officially wore out its welcome — with an It Follows-shaped asterisk hanging over the premise?
Its footprint
The marketing outlived the discourse: Paramount planted actors with frozen, unblinking grins behind home plate at televised MLB games, and the images went instantly viral — the 'Smile smiler' became a meme before most people saw the movie.
Where it stands
A crowd-pleaser more than a cinephile darling — a modern multiplex-horror touchstone that Letterboxd mostly rates 'pretty good,' then upgrades in hindsight for launching the series.
Did you know? Smile was originally made to stream on Paramount+, but test screenings scored so well that Paramount flipped it to a full theatrical release — where the roughly $17M film grossed over $215M worldwide.
Named by the director
- Cure (1997) — Finn has cited Kiyoshi Kurosawa's Cure as a key influence on Smile's creeping, contagion-like dread.
- Rosemary's Baby (1968) — Finn pointed to Polanski's paranoid, locked-to-one-woman's-perspective horror as a model for how Smile stays inside Rose's unraveling.
- Jacob's Ladder (1990) — Finn named it among the reality-bending psychological horrors that shaped Smile's is-this-really-happening texture.