Sightlines · reception
How Nightmare Alley was received
2021 · Guillermo del Toro · Nightmare Alley on Sightlines
The arc
It landed with a thud in December 2021 — buried at the box office by Spider-Man: No Way Home the same weekend — then rebounded with four Oscar nominations including Best Picture, and has been steadily climbing in estimation as one of del Toro's most rewatchable films.
What’s debated
Fans still argue over the slow-burn carnival first half versus the icy noir second half — and whether del Toro's version justifies itself next to the 1947 Tyrone Power original.
Its footprint
Its final scene and last line are treated as an all-timer ending among film fans — endlessly cited (spoiler-free) as one of the great closing beats of the 2020s — and the word 'geek' carries a whole new weight after you've seen it.
Where it stands
A canon climber: the rare recent Best Picture nominee that flopped, got shrugged at, and is now regularly defended as underrated del Toro.
Did you know? A month after release, del Toro put out a black-and-white cut in select theaters — 'Nightmare Alley: Vision in Darkness and Light' — arguing the film was conceived with classic noir monochrome in mind. It's also his first film with no supernatural element whatsoever.
Named by the director
- Nightmare Alley (1947) — Del Toro acknowledged Edmund Goulding's original but publicly insisted his film re-adapts William Lindsay Gresham's novel directly, deliberately not remaking the 1947 version.