
2016 · Keith Maitland
How Tower has been received, argued over, and remembered.
An instant SXSW 2016 sensation — it took both the Documentary Grand Jury and Audience awards — and then became one of that year's notorious Oscar stories when it made the Best Documentary shortlist but missed the final five. A decade on, it's a fixture of 'the Academy blew it' lists and a quiet canon entry for animated documentary.
The perennial fight is over the rotoscoped animation itself: is animating a real mass shooting a distancing aesthetic gimmick, or the only humane way to put you inside that day without exploiting archival horror?
Alongside Waltz with Bashir, it's become a go-to reference point for what animated documentary can do, and it gets re-invoked in the discourse every time campus gun violence returns to the headlines — its release landed almost exactly on the event's 50th anniversary.
On Letterboxd it lives as a beloved hidden-gem documentary — the four-star doc people press on friends with 'trust me, the animation is the point' — and a standard answer to 'best doc the Oscars ever snubbed.'