
1952 · Charlie Chaplin
How Limelight has been received, argued over, and remembered.
In 1952 it was less reviewed than boycotted — Chaplin's re-entry permit to the US was revoked while he sailed to the London premiere, and American Legion pressure kept the film out of much of the country. Europe embraced it immediately, and it's since settled in as his great autumnal masterpiece.
The perennial fight: is Limelight profoundly moving or Chaplin at his most sentimental and self-mythologising — a debate sharpened by the fact that the film is transparently about Chaplin himself.
This is the film where Chaplin and Buster Keaton finally share the screen — the only time the two titans of silent comedy ever appeared together, and one of the most cherished scenes in film history. Its theme, 'Eternally' (Terry's Theme), escaped the film to become a pop standard.
A 'late Chaplin makes you sob' staple among cinephiles — less quoted than City Lights or Modern Times, but often the one die-hards call his most personal.