
1987 · Norman Jewison
How Moonstruck has been received, argued over, and remembered.
A genuine hit in 1987 — three Oscars, including Cher for Best Actress — it was received as a charming crowd-pleaser, but decades on it's been upgraded to something closer to the great American romantic comedy, a 'they don't make them like this anymore' touchstone. Nicolas Cage's operatic performance, which struck some 1987 viewers as bizarre, now reads as early proof of concept for everything people love about him.
The perennial fight is over Cage: is his wild, opera-pitched performance the best thing in the movie or an act of lunacy the film somehow survives — and, relatedly, whether Moonstruck is a 'perfect movie' or just a very cozy one.
Cher's 'Snap out of it!' — delivered with a double slap — is one of the most quoted, GIF'd moments in rom-com history and made the AFI's list of great movie quotes; between that, the Dean Martin 'That's Amore' needle-drop, and the big moon over Brooklyn, the film is shorthand for swooning Italian-American romance.
Comfort-watch canon at this point: a fixture of best-rom-coms-ever lists, a Letterboxd perennial, and the standard answer to 'name a warm movie everyone actually likes.'