Sightlines · reception
How Remarkably Bright Creatures was received
2026 · Olivia Newman · Remarkably Bright Creatures on Sightlines
The arc
Critics shrugged at launch in May 2026 — 'Sally Field deserves better' pieces abounded — but audiences promptly cried their eyes out and made it the most-watched streaming film in the world its opening week, with the audience score running well ahead of the critics'.
What’s debated
The fault line is book readers vs. everyone else: did the film capture the magic of Shelby Van Pelt's beloved novel, or flatten a book-club phenomenon into Netflix comfort food?
Its footprint
Its cultural signature is 'I just sobbed over a CGI octopus' — Marcellus instantly joined My Octopus Teacher in the canon of internet octopus obsession, with octopus fan communities embracing the film as their mainstream moment.
Where it stands
Too new for cinephile canon and unlikely to enter it — it lives as a book-club tearjerker and a Sally-Field-is-a-national-treasure entry, the kind of film Letterboxd reviews with a crying emoji rather than an essay.
Did you know? Marcellus is fully CG (by Untold Studios), but every behavior he performs was modeled on a real giant Pacific octopus named Agnetha at the Vancouver Aquarium, whom the VFX team filmed for hours months before production — the crew watched hundreds of hours of octopus footage so he never does anything a real octopus couldn't.
Named by the director
- My Octopus Teacher (2020) — Newman has said watching it sparked her fascination with octopuses, which she carried into imagining Marcellus and the film's inside-the-tank point of view.